🏠

This is a hand-edited transcription produced from Scans by Bayerische Staatsbibliothek using OCRmyPDF and translated with GPT4 via ChatGPT

THIRTEENTH DISCOURSE

SEVENTH PREDICAMENT. Ubi, or Where.

Regarding the last four accidents that admit category, the first is Ubi (Latin adverb) interrogating about place, or position in it, which corresponds in Castilian to the adverb Donde (Where), from which are derived Por donde (By where), and Adonde (To where), which are used in this Science.

Donde is defined as such: It is an accident that results from the acquired position in a certain place, and of the subject, or action, that is placed in it: e.g., how each of the fighters is placed, or is positioned, with respect to themselves, and with respect to their opponent, from which results a certain external accident to each one, or to one, and to the other; in such a way, that the term Donde is recognized, in whose meaning the main placement is explained, from which the other two adverbs Por donde, and Adonde are derived, and all three comprehend certain principle: mean, that guides; end, or final term: demonstrating the position, either as mean, or as end; and in all terms this accident is recognized as a real entity in this Science.

Against this conclusion, it is usually argued, saying: Ubi is a Predicament that ends local movement. This nomination, then, is not a real entity, but positive: therefore this Predicament Ubi is not for a real entity. To which it is answered: Every ended term, and its derivatives admit real entity: the term Ubi (the same as Donde) and its derivatives signify properly ended term: therefore the Ubi Predicamental, and its derivatives are perceived as real entity. The reason is, because the adverb Ubi categorically demonstrates the denomination by place, or position; in such a way, that it supposes reality of that which has a precise being really, either it is considered as principle, either as mean, or as end. Therefore, that which has a precise being, and not contingent, is a real entity: therefore the Predicament Ubi, and its derivatives, admit real entity, and not only positive.

For this reason, the ancient and modern dictionaries explain the word Ubi as an adverb of precise place, although with different punctuations, like Ubi? questioning: others, as relative, that means Por donde, and thus it is medial, as a precise and finished concept, and not as a contingent one: in others it is finite, and demonstrates term of conclusion in a determined place, and in all three modes it is real entity: and as such, it is admitted in this Science, and not as positive entity, nor as pure entity of reason, nor as objective concept; rather in the exercise it is perceived, forming a mathematical entity proceeding from the real entity. The reason why in this Science, and its operations, it is necessary, that they be regulated, and understood by this adverb, and its derivatives, is, because no action, or term, can be without occupying a place, according to the terms of this Predicament, because the Tactics, that are done governing the instrument Sword, it is necessary that they have a principle, De donde they begin, transit Por donde they guide, and determined end, Adonde they execute, disposing themselves by these terms to the perfection, that the common people call Dexterity, with which is achieved the own defense, and the offense in the opposite opponent, for whose intelligence a Schema is formed.

SCHEMA OF THE WHERE

  • Where
    • Where
      • Natural
        • By real placement
      • Accidental
        • By positions, which are produced from the first placement
        • Or because they are succeeding one another
    • Through where
      • Means between the extremes, which leads to the final term
    • To where
      • End, or conclusion of the action
      • By consummation of the act
      • Or by final existence